Sal's NY Pizza

Lyconia Mccaffity 2 months ago

This was my first time visiting here. I noticed an employee eating in the area where they cook so that was disgusting. The chicken wings were hard but the pizza was good. Not sure if I would return to this location due to the staff eating over the food. Like so many things going on right now in the world with food people getting sick. So I prayed over my food but just seeing that was something.

Cassie M 2 months ago

Choose another place. We ordered delivery to our hotel (we're traveling for work and vacation). I called up to the restaurant and asked them to make sure they put cheese and chili pepper packets. They said they were out of both. I asked if they could please make sure they put some in containers with the order. They said they promised they would. When it was scheduled to arrive, it never showed up. Then it showed delivered on the app. We called the restaurant and it turns out they delivered it to the wrong hotel. They remade it. Brought it out again. Ask me if they brought the cheese and peppers. No. They said they gave it to the first hotel. Fine. Should be excellent pizza right? Of course not. I've never had a more tasteless pizza. We both agreed that this was as far from NY Style pizza as you can get. It taste like if you tried to make pizza at home with your kids for the first time. Flat crust, not enough sauce, ingredients that disappeared into bland cheese. It just tasted like disappointment. I ate 3 slices because we waited so long and I was hungry. They never offered a discount or anything for the inconvenience. Definitely not worth the time or money. 10/10 wouldn'

Brian Etheridge 3 months ago

I saw Sal’s New York Pizza driving by and thought man that place looks like great pizza. If this is New York pizza then I’m in no hurry to go get some. Dry, no taste at all and I don’t even think the cheese was mozzarella. I ordered extra cheese and pepperoni. I can see that sauce through the cheese. Also going in felt awkward. Walked up to counter and folks behind counter just looking at me. One fella sitting there on his phone. I thought alright even the guys are giving New York treatment this pizza is going to be great! Nope! Waste of 23 dollars. Wawa has better pizza than this place.

frankiy braga 5 months ago

Just ordered from here the first time. Was awesome pizza and I got a large. And it was actually a large! I got the margerhita pizza. Very good, on the sweet sauce side and the fresh basil on top nice spread out mozzarella 👌. The pizza itself was a nice even thinness even the crust. Perfecto! Not greasy or oily. The wings were very nice sauce was tangy and hot but not overwhelming and you get and good amount. The dessert was a tiramisu. Love a tiramisu. I do not know if they make it in house or not. But it was decently good. Better tiramisu than some other places ahaha. At least this one had coffee in it. All in all was a good experience clean work space and shop.

Deja O 7 months ago

The first time I ordered from here, the pizza was great. The second time, not so much. I kept hearing great things about them and that they’re supposed to be the closest to authentic New York–style pizza around, so I figured maybe I just had an off experience and decided to give them another try. Unfortunately, it still wasn’t good in my opinion. The pizza was very dry, bland and seemed overcooked. There was barely any sauce..and the layer of cheese was extremely thin. The crust was also quite hard, which made it difficult to eat.. I couldn’t even pick at the cheese, it was so dried out and some parts of the slice were almost bare. I actually had to dip the pizza in store-bought marinara just to get some flavor and attempt to soften it. Based on the reviews, I really wanted to like this place, but the last two times the pizza has been disappointing and a waste of money.